Skip to main content

Become an Apple Subscriber or Patron to listen.

In March 1993, 19-year-old college student Christa Sallani was living in the quiet town of Sheridan. Wyoming, working late-night shifts at a local convenience store while pursuing her dream of becoming a dietitian. 

On the night of March 12, 1993, Christa finished her shift & headed home, completely unaware that her life was about to take a horrifying turn.

The murder of Christa Sallani

Although she was nowhere to be found the following day, her car was parked outside her apartment with the driver’s side door open with some of her personal belongings scattered nearby, making it clear that something was not right.

As an investigation began, authorities came to learn that Christa had been receiving a series of disturbing phone calls during late night shifts at the convenience store. The mysterious caller, who identified himself as John, told her that he could see her inside the store from where he was calling.  

For more than a year, her family desperately waited for answers until a discovery in a nearby creek confirmed their worst nightmare. 

Identifying Christa’s killer would prove to be far from simple since there was little physical evidence, conflicting accounts & a suspect whose story would change multiple times. Piece-by-piece, investigators began to assemble a picture of what happened to Christa, uncovering a disturbing series of events that ultimately led to the murder of a young woman who had her entire life ahead of her.

19-year-old Christa Sallani had been a sophomore at Sheridan College in Sheridan, Wyoming at the northern portion of the state, only 25 miles from the Montana border. During the early 1990s, Sheridan had a population of about 14,000 residents.

Christa had been raised primarily by her mom, Myra Coster, as the middle child. Myra moved to Sheridan in 1988 with her three daughters, Christa, Dallas & Lee. She described Christa as a very particular child who loved to ride horses & had a pony named Cinnamon that she adored. She was a dedicated, hard-working girl who always had good grades & loved school.

In 1993, Christa was living in an apartment with a roommate, but remained close with her mom & sisters. Not only was she a full-time student, but she also worked the night shift full-time at the Maverick convenience store where her mom worked as well. 

Despite the fact that she wasn’t living at home at the time, Myra saw her daughter basically every day since Christa often stopped by to visit with them.

The murder of Christa Sallani

On Friday, March 12, 1993, Christa clocked into work at about 5 pm & she clocked out at 12:46 am, now on Saturday morning, March 13. When her roommate woke up later that morning, she saw that Christa’s car was in the parking lot, but she didn’t see Christa.

The murder of Christa Sallani

When Myra came into work on Saturday evening, she was told that her daughter hadn’t shown up for her shift that day & no one had heard from her. Since Christa was an extremely reliable person who would have called had she been unable to make it, this was highly out of character for her. Myra was immediately worried so she contacted the Sheridan police to file a missing person report.

When officers responded to Christa’s apartment, they found the driver’s side door of her car wide open with some of her personal belongings scattered on the ground nearby, including a book, her contact lens solution & her keys.

In speaking with those who knew Christa, they came to learn that she was a very mature young woman who put school & work before partying. Based on the picture that was quickly coming together, investigators believed that Christa had been abducted after she climbed out of her car in the early morning hours of Saturday, March 13. 

At the time of her disappearance, Sheridan was a place where residents felt safe to the point that they often left their doors unlocked. 

Early on, local police officers reached out to the FBI for assistance in hopes of obtaining a psychological profile of a potential offender, however, since they had such little information with no crime scene or a body, they were unable to help. Officers canvassed the area, interviewing neighbors in hopes that someone may have seen or heard something on the night that Christa vanished.

Search parties were assembled, but they found no sign of her. Myra was wracked with fear, unsure of where her daughter was or what may have happened to her. 

In the immediate days following her disappearance, a man named Carl Haler came forward to tell detectives that he had visited Christa a couple of times at the convenience store on the evening of March 12. He didn’t know her well, but he admitted that he found her attractive & wanted to get to know her. 

When he initially came in to buy a soda & chat, Christa asked him if he was John, explaining that someone named John had been calling her at work & they planned to come by to see her. 

When Carl came back a second time after dinner to continue their conversation, Christa got a phone call from the person identifying himself as John, telling Christa, I can see you from where I’m calling you. When she looked out the window, she didn’t see anyone.  

When Carl called to check on her at about midnight, he heard someone walk into the store & say, I’m John. When he asked Christa if it was John, she told him it was before she said she’d better go & quickly ended the call. 

Investigators were intrigued by what Carl told them, realizing he could either be telling the truth or making the story up to lead them astray. If he was telling the truth, they needed to figure out the identity of the mystery man named John. 

They were unsure what to think of Carl when he went on to say that the women in his life tended to have bad luck, that something bad inevitably happened to them while he was dating them. Now estranged from his wife, one of his girlfriends had died in a car accident & now something bad had no doubt happened to Christa.

As they began trying to determine who John was, Carl was the sole suspect in Christa’s disappearance at the time. 

Days later, a rancher came forward, telling investigators that at 3 am on Saturday, March 13, a man had come to his ranch house along Big Goose Creek Road & woke him & his wife up. He said that his Ford Bronco had gone off the road & got stuck in a ditch, asking the rancher if he would help him tow his car out.

Not only was the location only a short distance from where Christa worked, but it was right around the time she may have been abducted. When the police contacted the towing service, they came to learn that the man was 26-year-old Tommy Kolb.

The murder of Christa Sallani

When investigators spoke with Kolb, he explained that he’d been out drinking downtown on Friday night, March 12, when he heard there was a party southwest of town on Red Grade Road. While he was on his way out there, he drove over the bridge on Beckton Road & his car slid into a ditch. He told detectives that he didn’t know Christa & hadn’t gone to the convenience store where she worked.

A massive search party was organized for the specific area where Kolb’s car had gone off the road but there was still no sign of Christa.

As the months continued to pass, Myra described her life as a blur. Although she continued to work & take care of her two daughters, she was in pain every moment of every day, not knowing what had become of her daughter. Since she didn’t know where she was, she maintained a level of hope that Christa could potentially still be alive. Meanwhile, investigators knew that a predator was still on the loose.

Nearly one year later, on March 29, 1994, a father & son were out fishing on Big Goose Creek when the son’s fishing line caught on something. After he pulled a white jacket from the water, he unzipped one of the pockets & found a Sheridan College library card as well as a Wyoming driver’s license, both of which had Christa’s photo & name on them. 

The murder of Christa Sallani

Learning that her daughter’s coat had been found, the small sense of hope Myra held that her daughter could still be alive, completely died.

Following the discovery of the coat, investigators re-interviewed Tommy Kolb, but his story remained consistent. They went on to re-interview every potential suspect & witness associated with the case, including Carl Haler, who had been interviewed several times. Like Kolb, he maintained his original story.

Tom Kolb & Carl Haler remained persons of interest in the case, but when the area around where the coat had been found was searched, nothing more was found & once again, the investigation hit a dead end.

Three months later on June 5, 1994, the case was blown wide open when three boys were out swimming in Big Goose Creek several miles downstream from where Christa’s jacket had been found. When one of the boys stepped down, his foot hit something sharp & he thought he may have cut his foot. Reaching down, he pulled up the face plate of a human skull with the lower jaw missing with one tooth still attached.

After the portion of skull was sent to forensic anthropologist, Dr. George Gill, although much of it was missing, he was able to determine that it belonged to a caucasian female. Since her third molar had erupted, the victim had been 18 or a little older. Christa was the only missing person in the area that fit this description. 

When the skull was compared against her dental records, it was a definitive match to Christa Sallani. Myra was understandably devastated by the news, knowing that her daughter would never be coming home.

Starting back at square one, investigators questioned every witness & potential suspect once again. While it seemed less likely that Carl Haler was Christa’s killer, it seemed that much more likely Tommy Kolb was since  his car went off the road only 200 yards from where Christa’s coat had been found.

On July 28, 1994, investigators requested that Kolb come in for a third conversation with them. He agreed & came in at about 5 pm after he was done with his job as a mechanic. During an in-depth interview, his story initially stayed consistent with what he’d always said & they found him to be very cooperative. Regardless, his story just wasn’t sitting well with Agent Kevin Hughes.

As Hughes continued to press him, he was shocked to learn that Kolb had been previously arrested for kidnapping & sexual assault in Lincoln County, Colorado. Because of a clerical error, his information hadn’t been submitted to the state of Colorado which meant that Wyoming investigators knew nothing about it. 

Learning this information, they felt convinced that Tom Kolb was Christa’s killer. Continuing to question him, he was asked if he’d noticed any cameras on the Sheridan Police Department which was positioned across the street from the convenience store where Christa worked. Although there were no cameras, it gave Kolb the impression that they had surveillance footage.

He immediately told them that he & Christa had been having an affair for about a month before she vanished, but they had yet to be intimate. This was the first time he acknowledged knowing her. 

Not only did he acknowledge knowing her, but he also admitted to being with her on the night she vanished when his wife had been out of town. He said they met up at a local park after her shift ended & they kissed. Feeling guilty for cheating on his wife, he went for a drive after, which was when his car slid off the road. 

After he agreed to allow his Bronco to be searched, investigators told him they planned to utilize Luminal to test for the presence of blood, which was when his story changed yet again. He claimed that while they had been in his car together that night, they began playfully wrestling when he accidentally head-butted her, causing a nosebleed. 

As detectives continued to press him, fully doubting that he had been having an affair with Christa, he finally admitted that he was John, the man who had been calling Christa at work.

When Agent Hughes asked if there was any way that a witness could have seen his Bronco at Christa’s apartment in the early morning hours of Saturday, March 13, 1993, he said yes. He admitted that he stalked Christa at the convenience store using the alias John. He followed her after work & became enraged when she chose to go home to her apartment rather than going to a party with him. 

After they pulled into the parking lot of her apartment complex, he began yelling at her, pulling her belongings from her car in anger, throwing them to the pavement. He claimed he got back into his car & went home.

After a cigarette break, he admitted that he hadn’t just gone home after following Christa. Instead, when she got out of her car to go into her apartment, he tackled her from behind, putting her in a sleeper hold as they both fell to the ground, causing her belongings to fall as Christa lost consciousness. 

He put her over his shoulder in a fireman’s carry, putting her into his Bronco & driving off. When Christa regained consciousness about ten minutes later, she threatened to tell the police as well as his wife so he grabbed a hammer from his toolbox & began striking her in the head with it as well as his fists. He told Agent Hughes that while he’d been striking her, he lost control of his car, driving off the road & into the ditch. 

As detectives drove him out to the area in question, Kolb told them that he struck her with the hammer with the intention of killing her because he didn’t want her to tell his wife. After his Broco crashed, Christa ran for her life in the direction of Big Goose Creek as Kolb chased after her.

When she got caught up on a fence line near the water, she managed to slip out of her coat to free herself before she continued running. When he caught up to her at the edge of the creek, he tackled her to the ground, holding her face under the freezing cold water, drowning her.

He carried her body away from the creek, concealing her remains in a remote, rugged area further down the mountain where a widespread search turned up her scattered skeletal remains after Kolb agreed to lead law enforcement to the disposal site.

After three taped confessions, Kolb was arrested for the kidnapping & murder of Christa Sallani on July 28, 1994. 

The murder of Christa Sallani

After he recanted his confessions, claiming he had only told the investigators what they wanted to hear so he could escape the high-pressure interrogation, he pleaded not guilty & his trial began in February 1995, nearly two years after Christa’s murder. 

When Kolb testified in his own defense, he spoke about a fence that was near Christa’s apartment complex which placed him with Christa at the scene where she had been abducted.

Prosecutors had built a strong case combining his own recorded statements, circumstantial evidence & corroborating witness testimonies. Although the physical evidence was limited because Christa’s body had been severely scattered by the elements & animals, the timeline & geographic tracking was overwhelming. He knocked on the rancher’s door at 3 am asking for help while the towing log proved that his Bronco was pulled from a ditch directly adjacent to Big Goose Creek at that exact hour.

Christa’s jacket had been found only a few hundred meters from the exact ditch where his vehicle had gone off the road.

The defense tried to argue that Christa could have suffered a medical emergency & accidentally fallen into the river & drowned. Forensic anthropologist Dr. George Gill was able to successfully disprove this based on the severe scatter of the subsequent skeletal remains that were found high on the mountain terrain exactly where Kolb later led investigators which was completely inconsistent with a simple drowning accident.

After four hours of deliberations, the jury came back with a unanimous verdict on Saturday, February 11, 1995, finding Tom Kolb guilty of the first-degree murder & aggravated kidnapping of Christa Sallani. He was given two consecutive life sentences in prison. 

After appealing his conviction, the state Supreme Court reviewed the case & upheld his conviction on December 20, 1996.

When 19-year-old Christa Sallani was murdered in March 1993, she had been an incredibly determined young woman who was working toward a future she never got to experience. For more than a year, her family was left to live with the uncertainty of not knowing where she was or what had happened to her. When they finally did get answers, they were far more devastating than they could have imagined.

References:

  1. HBO Max: True Conviction: S2, E 9: John is Calling
  2. The Cinemalholic: Christa Sallani murder: Where is Tommy Kolb now?
  3. Justia U.S. Law: Kolb v. State
  4. Medium: She vanished after her night shift. A year later, a boy found the evidence that exposed her killer
  5. Wikipedia: Sheridan, Wyoming

Leave a Reply