Watch on YouTube. Listen on Apple or Spotify.
On a Saturday morning in December 2000, 31-year-old Mike Williams left his Tallahassee, Florida home well before sunrise to go duck hunting on Lake Seminole. He told his wife Denise that he would be home at noon so they could celebrate their 6th wedding anniversary together.
When evening came & Mike still hadn’t come home, Denise reported him missing, prompting a massive search of the lake. Although Mike’s boat was found early the next morning, since there was absolutely no sign of him, investigators concluded that he must have accidentally fallen overboard & drowned. When his body wasn’t found, they began to theorize that his remains must have been consumed by alligators.
For nearly two decades, this was the only explanation that anyone had to offer, while Mike’s mom refused to believe this. Her mother’s intuition told her that her son had been murdered & his disappearance had been staged.
It would take nearly 17 years & an entirely separate crime before investigators finally uncovered the truth of what really happened to Mike on that December morning.

Jerry Michael “Mike” Williams met Denise Merrell while they were high school students at North Florida Christian School in Tallahassee. While Mike was a football player, president of the student council & voted best personality, Denise was a cheerleader, secretary of the student council & voted best dressed.
Denise had been raised in a very religious, middle-class family. She had always been well-liked in school, especially with the boys. Mike came from a blue-collar family where his dad worked as a Greyhound bus driver while his mom stayed home with the kids, running an in-home daycare. He was a kind person who was loved by all who knew him.
During high school, Mike & Denise became inseparable with another couple, Brian Winchester & Kathy Aldredge. After their graduation in 1988, their tight-knit friendship carried on into adulthood. They ended up buying a house, getting married & having their first child around the same time as one another.

After Mike & Denise each graduated from Florida State University, Denise became an accountant for the state while Mike worked as a real estate appraiser. They were married on December 17, 1994 & they welcomed their baby girl, Anslee, into their lives 4 ½ years later just before Mother’s Day of 1999.
As for Brian & Kathy, Brian had always been more of an introvert while Kathy was an outgoing cheerleader who wanted to get involved in as many school activities as she could. Brian proposed in 1993 when they had been dating for seven years & they were married seven months before Mike & Denise in May 1994.

Mike & Denise seemed to truly have a truly picture-perfect life together. They settled close to where they were both raised, they had a gorgeous, healthy baby girl, a close group of friends & Mike was making good money as a real estate appraiser.
According to Patti Ketcham, who worked with Mike at a real estate agency for nearly fifteen years, he had the strongest work ethic of anyone she’d ever met, many times working 15-hour days. Every bit of success he had, had been earned.
Despite his dedication to work, Mike always prioritized Denise, running back home to fill up her gas tank when she needed it or doing other thoughtful things. Although they had severely grown apart by winter of 2000, since their 6th anniversary was approaching, Mike planned a weekend getaway for them at the Gibson Inn, a historic bed & breakfast in Apalachicola, Florida.
Since they weren’t leaving until Saturday afternoon on December 16, 2000, one day before their actual anniversary, Mike scheduled a quick duck hunting trip at Lake Seminole at dawn, promising Denise he would be back at noon. Denise’s parents were scheduled to watch 18-month-old Anslee while they were gone overnight.

Mike left in his Ford Bronco well before sunrise that morning with his boat in tow to make the hour-long drive to Lake Seminole in Sneads, Florida.
Moving forward to noon, Kathy Winchester recalls her phone ringing, finding Denise on the other end. She asked if she knew where Brian or Mike were since Mike hadn’t come home as planned, but Kathy hadn’t heard from anyone that day. Since duck hunting season only spanned from Thanksgiving until the end of January, it was very common for Brian to be out early on a near-daily basis. As they talked, Kathy could hear the irritation in her friend’s voice.
Kathy, Brian & their son had plans to drive up to her grandma’s house in Cairo, Georgia, 28 miles north of Tallahassee, to celebrate Christmas early with her family. When Brian wasn’t home by 2 pm that afternoon, Kathy packed up her son & she left without him. When Brian arrived sometime between 4-5 pm that evening, he said he wasn’t sure where Mike was since they hadn’t been out hunting together that morning.
When they got back home that night, Brian’s dad called to let them know that Mike still hadn’t come home, so they needed to drive out to Lake Seminole to help search for him. While he left for the lake, Kathy headed over to Denise’s house where her family had already begun to gather.

At this point, everyone felt confident that there would be an innocent explanation as to why Mike hadn’t come home yet; maybe his boat had run out of gas. Although he was a very experienced hunter, Mike wasn’t a strong swimmer. He also normally hunted wearing waders, something that put him at a greater risk of drowning should he accidentally fall overboard since they would fill with water, pulling him under.
Although it had been a gorgeous 72 ℉/22 ℃ on Saturday, by nightfall, a strong cold front swept through the area around Lake Seminole, causing temperatures to drop into as low as into the teens.
As the search began, Mike’s abandoned boat was found early the next morning tucked into the weeds on the western shore of the lake with some decoys & his shotgun on board. The motor was off, the kill switch was still attached, the gas tank was full & the boat was undamaged. His Bronco & trailer were also found parked near the lake.
While the Jackson County Sheriff’s heat seeking helicopter found no sign of Mike, cadaver dogs were brought in while teams scoured the murky bottom of the lake in search of Mike’s body. Since the lake’s surface was covered in a thick layer of a plant called hydrilla, they were unable to see under the surface of the water. Using PVC pipes, searches poked them down into the water to see if they could feel anything. They knew if they were to hit a log, they would feel a hard thump, but if they were to hit a body, it would feel more like a pillow.
Since Lake Seminole is loaded with alligators, those searching for Mike couldn’t help but wonder what would have become of him had he accidentally fallen overboard.
In the United States, alligators live anywhere from the Rio Grande River in Texas across the southeast up to a maximum northern range of North Carolina. Although they prefer fresh water environments, they rarely live within more than a few hundred miles of the ocean.

While wild & dangerous, alligator attacks are fairly rare & they eat humans even less commonly. Only a small fraction of attacks are deadly & oftentimes, the remains are found intact after an attack. According to the Florida Fish & Wildlife Conservation Commission, between 1948-2019, of the total of 401 unprovoked alligator attacks on humans in Florida, only 25 resulted in fatalities.
After the pain getting through Christmas not knowing where Mike was, searchers continued a recovery mission along the lake. On the tenth day of the search, Mike’s hat was found in the lake. After forty-four days of finding no trace of Mike, the search was called off & he was listed as still missing.
Mike’s mother, Cheryl Williams, felt very strongly that her son was not in that lake since Mike was such an experienced hunter who knew Lake Seminole like the back of his hand.
Since the creation of the lake was completed in 1957 all the way up to 2025, of the just over 100 people who have drowned in Lake Seminole, Mike’s was the only body that wasn’t recovered.
In June 2001, about six months after Mike went missing, a local fisherman found Mike’s chest-high waders in Lake Seminole in an area that had been searched many times. Two days later, his hunting jacket was found at the same spot with one sleeve pulled inside out. In the pocket was his hunting license along with a flashlight that still worked.
With no further sign of him, the assumption was made that he’d accidentally fallen out of the boat, his waders filled with water & an alligator ultimately consumed his remains. However, the waders were described as being in pristine condition. Not only was there no damage suggestive of an alligator attack, but they also weren’t slimy as would be expected from being submerged in the lake for six months.
Regardless of what authorities were telling her, Cheryl Williams refused to believe this. For nine years, she wrote a letter to the governor on a daily basis, amounting to 1,472 letters in total, urging state officials to investigate her son’s death further.

Not only did it not make sense that his waders or jacket hadn’t been found sooner despite six months of searching the lake, but she had also contacted an alligator expert from Florida who told her that alligators do not feed in northern Florida in December when ambient or water temperatures drop below about 70 degrees. He also told her that when alligators do kill, there’s always forensic evidence left behind, making the theory around Mike’s case virtually impossible.
However, as morbid as it sounds, alligators have been known to store remains in a location that searchers wouldn’t be able to find before coming back six months later to feed.
Cheryl’s ongoing insistence that Mike didn’t drown in Lake Seminole caused major fractures in her relationship with Denise, who asked her to stop pushing the issue, saying she didn’t even want to hear Mike’s name again since she wanted to get on with her life.
In the immediate aftermath of his disappearance, while they gathered together at Mike & Denise’s home, Cheryl indicated that Denise stayed upstairs in her room, too upset to interact. However, as the days continued to pass, Cheryl began to see her daughter-in-law’s actions resembling relief rather than grief.
According to Cheryl, Denise told her that if she didn’t stop pushing for further investigation, she wouldn’t allow her to remain in Anslee’s life. Sadly, she made good on her ultimatum as both Cheryl & Mike’s brother, Nick, haven’t seen Anslee since January 2005 when she was 5-years-old.
Despite her threats, Cheryl refused to let things go, believing in her heart that Mike had been murdered & someone had staged his death to look like a drowning. With her ongoing persistence, her son’s case was finally re-opened in 2004 when a multi-agency investigation was launched.
Investigators came to find that there were many reasons to be suspicious. For one, over a 71 year span of time, only 25 alligator attacks had resulted in fatalities while in the majority of these cases, the remains were found intact.
Even more intriguing, Mike had a total of $1.75 million in life insurance policies. Since his best friend, Brian Winchester, worked for his family’s business at Winchester Financial Group, he initially sold Mike a $250,000 policy in 1993 or 1994. Six months to a year before his death, he sold him another policy for $1 million. Brian was also aware that Mike had a third policy from another company for $500,000 that he planned to allow to lapse & be replaced with the new $1 million policy.
According to Florida law, a person has to be missing for a continuous period of five years before a legal presumption of death can be established, allowing a beneficiary to collect life insurance payouts.
Brian voiced his concerns about Denise having to wait so long since she became a single mother overnight. She would have to go back to work in order to support herself & her daughter.
Investigators also found it highly coincidental that Mike’s waders & jacket just so happened to surface less than a month before the court hearing in which Denise needed proof that her husband was dead in order to collect the insurance money. Not to mention, because they were found in such good condition, suggested someone may have planted the items.
When Denise filed claims for the life insurance money only 19 days after Mike went missing on January 4, 2001, she requested that the policy proceeds be paid immediately based on an accidental drowning. Since a massive search was still actively underway & no body had been found, she was told that funds wouldn’t be paid without a legally binding death certificate.
After Mike’s waders & jacket surfaced, this evidence allowed her to convince a Leon County judge to fast-track a death certificate on June 29 & she received it a month later on July 29, 2001, which allowed her to successfully collect the $1.75 million by September.
According to Kathy, she & Brian had tremendously grown apart in the months leading up to Mike’s death since she was ready to settle down & focus on their son while Brian still wanted to drink & party. After Mike went missing, she could see that Brian had made himself available to Denise in every way possible in a way he’d never done for her.
Kathy was at work in March 2001 when Brian called to tell her he was taking their dogs to a training session. Since something in her gut made her question him, after she decided to come home on her lunch break at about 2 pm, she saw that the dogs were home, but Brian wasn’t.
Later that evening, when she asked him about his day, he told her he’d taken the dogs at 2 pm, exactly the time she’d been home with them. Pressing him for the truth, Brian eventually told her that Denise had wanted to go to the lake for her birthday since she hadn’t been back since Mike went missing, so he’d gone with her. She couldn’t understand why he wouldn’t have just told her in the first place if he hadn’t been doing anything wrong.
When Kathy went down to her husband’s office & looked through his desk drawers, she found a receipt for a jewelry store at the mall for a necklace with Denise’s nickname, Meridian, written in gold. She was shellshocked that someone she had been best friends with since school had betrayed her in such a way.

Not long after, Kathy got a letter from a man named Chuck Bunker, who began dating Denise in the summer of 2002, a year & a half after Mike went missing. He not only wanted her to know about an incident he had with Brian & Denise in Atlanta, but also to let her know that Brian & Denise had been living a double life that very few people were aware of.
Denise & Chuck met at the Florida State Board of Administration where Chuck worked & where Denise had been looking for a job. When they went to Atlanta together in 2003, Brian found out about it, tracked them down & confronted them in the hotel lobby. He flew into a jealous rage, voicing suicidal as well as homicidal threats. He also threatened to blackmail Denise if she didn’t get back together with him, mentioning compromising photos he had of her.
Although Chuck could see fear in Denise’s eyes, she ended their relationship in order to get back together with Brian.
Kathy came to learn that Brian & Denise had been having an affair since October 13, 1997 after they’d all gone to a Sister Hazel concert together. While Mike & Kathy were parking the car, Brian & Denise shared their first kiss inside the venue. Although they went home with their respective spouses, they spent the night talking & having phone sex.
Very quickly, their relationship escalated & they began meeting up anytime Mike was out of town for work, even taking trips together.
Although Kathy & Brian separated & were soon divorced, Brian initially kept his relationship with Denise underwraps, no doubt realizing how questionable it would look that he was dating his late best friend’s wife.
After Brian & Denise got married on December 3, 2005, four years after Mike went missing, Brian moved into the house Mike had purchased, sleeping in the marital bed he & Denise had shared before he vanished. He also stepped in as a father-figure for his best friend’s 6-year-old daughter, Anslee.
After Cheryl Williams was successfully able to get her son’s case reopened, Detective Derrick Wester of the Jackson County Sheriff’s Office came to speak with Kathy in 2004. By this time she had remarried & she was convinced that Brian & Denise were somehow responsible for Mike’s disappearance.
When Detective Wester asked her about the morning of Mike’s disappearance on Saturday, December 16, 2000, she told him that Brian was gone when she woke up, likely out hunting. She wasn’t sure where he was or if he was with anyone. When he wasn’t home by 2 pm, she left with their son to drive up to her grandma’s house in Georgia & when Brian finally arrived sometime between 4-5 pm, he quickly fell asleep on the couch.
When Detective Wester spoke with Brian about that day, his story was completely different. He said that when he woke up at 10 am, he went out into the yard to play with their dogs before he, Kathy & their son drove to her grandma’s house together.
Although he agreed to take a polygraph test, days later Brian’s lawyer contacted Detective Wester to say he wouldn’t be.
Moving forward to 2006, journalist Jennifer Portman saw an ad in the paper from Cheryl Williams, who continued to plead for help in finding her son. After connecting with Cheryl, she was determined to help the grieving mother, working closely with Detective Wester. The more she learned, the more shocked she was, especially when she realized how much money Denise had collected from her late husband’s life insurance policy.
Cheryl spoke with ATF special agent Josey Visnovske of the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms & Explosive since he was looking for a daycare for his child & she was a daycare provider. When she told him about Mike’s case, Josey immediately saw it as a no-brainer, believing someone had no doubt killed Mike.
He wasn’t able to get involved in the case until Cheryl told him that Denise & Brian had an unaccounted for firearm in their possession that belonged to her late husband. Because they had an unregistered firearm, this fell under the federal jurisdiction of the ATF.
When Josey spoke with Kathy, she immediately agreed to help, hoping they could finally figure out what role Denise & Brian had each played in Mike’s death.
Josey began monitoring Brian & Denise’s home, something that according to Kathy, made Brian exceptionally paranoid. All the while, Jennifer Portman was keeping Mike’s case alive from an investigative standpoint.
When Brian contacted Kathy, saying he wanted to talk to her, Josey fitted her with a wire for their meeting at McDonalds on December 14, 2007, nearly 7 years to the day that Mike went missing. It was clear he was very suspicious when he refused to come inside, saying McDonalds had too many cameras.
Although he wanted to drive to the courthouse so Kathy would be forced to go through a metal detector, allowing him to see if she was wearing a wire, they ended up driving to another area.
Brian asked her about what she had been telling the authorities about the day Mike went missing, saying their son would be affected if she didn’t help him. Unfortunately, no confession came from their conversation, but Josey remained a pillar of personal & emotional support for Cheryl throughout her 17-year battle for justice.
After seven years of marriage, Denise & Brian separated in 2012 when she caught him having sex with another woman. According to his friends, Brian was miserable about losing his marriage & struggled to move on.
Moving forward four years to August 5, 2016, Denise got into her SUV & began driving to work when she saw Brian climb from the back toward her, pressing a gun into her ribs. Although he tried to overtake the car, Denise managed to pull the wheel back & park at a CVS knowing that there were cameras there. As customers filtered in & out of the store, he held her seatbelt so she couldn’t flee from the car.
He told her he just wanted to talk to her, that he had no choice but to do this since she wasn’t answering his calls or texts. After she was able to convince him to allow her to go to work, reassuring him that they would work things out & that she wouldn’t contact the police, she drove him back to his truck. Right before he got out of her SUV, he gathered his things from the back & Denise watched as he removed a tan sheet, a plastic tarp, a tool resembling a hammer as well as a spray bottle of bleach. These items made it obvious that Brian had intended to kill her & clean up the crime scene afterwards.
Rather than driving to work as she promised, Denise went straight to the Leon County Sheriff’s Office.
Although officers tried to use this opportunity to finally get Denise to admit that Brian had been responsible for Mike’s disappearance sixteen years earlier, she continued to maintain that she believed Mike died on the lake, that she would have never married Brian had she believed he was responsible for Mike’s death.
Brian was arrested at his office that day by a SWAT team & charged with kidnapping & aggravated assault. He denied holding Denise at gunpoint that day, saying he had only been trying to talk to her. His bail was denied & he remained behind bars.
By this time, Kathy & Denise had gotten close again, not because Kathy wanted to, but only because she hoped in doing so, Denise might confess to what happened to Mike. Knowing that Kathy was on her way to speak with Brian’s father, Marcus, Denise called her, asking that she pass a message to Marcus who could then pass the message to Brian. The message was, I’m not talking.

Kathy knew immediately that this was about Mike’s death, that it meant, I’m keeping our secret.
Facing as much as a life sentence for armed kidnapping & assault, in October 2017, Brian decided to make a deal with prosecutors while he remained behind bars, something that blew the whole case open nearly seventeen years after Mike went missing.
On October 4, 2017, Brian officially confessed to Mike’s murder during an hours-long taped confession with the Florida Department of Law Enforcement (FDLE).
In exchange for his full cooperation in finding Mike’s body & telling the State exactly what happened to him, they agreed not to pursue a life sentence in the kidnapping case. They also granted him immunity in Mike’s murder case. If he wasn’t truthful, the agreement was null & void.
He went on to tell officers that about a year & a half before Mike’s death, he & Denise started discussing different ways they could be together. Since she refused to get a divorce from Mike because she didn’t want to share custody of Anslee, this left murder as their only option.
They talked about various plots such as murdering him at his office so it appeared to be a robbery gone wrong. They also considered a boating trip with their respective spouses that involved killing both Kathy & Mike, making it look like a boating accident. Since Brian didn’t want to take his son’s mother from him, he refused to kill Kathy.
It was the third idea they came up with that they settled on, that Brian would go on a hunting trip with Mike & make it look like a drowning accident. They had a narrow window of time since not only did hunting season last for only a couple of months, but they also didn’t want Mike’s $500,000 insurance policy to lapse. Unbeknownst to Mike, Denise paid one more premium period to ensure the policy wouldn’t lapse .
Their sixth wedding anniversary was approaching & Mike could feel Denise pulling away from him, so he planned a getaway for one day before their actual anniversary on Saturday, December 16, 2000. Since Denise didn’t want to go away with her husband, she & Brian decided that would be the day to go through with their plan.
They initially planned on the week before, but one night before Mike was set to go hunting with Brian, Denise told her husband she didn’t want him to go so he cancelled it.
On Friday night, December 15, Brian planned to either get Kathy drunk or give her medication so she would sleep in on Saturday, allowing him to murder Mike & get home before she woke up. He would then make it look like he overslept for the hunting trip he had planned with his father-in-law.
Brian told officers that he told Mike that his phone wasn’t working to be sure he didn’t call him that morning so there was no evidence of them being together. They met up at a gas station early Saturday morning & Brian told him they were going to a secret spot for hunting, reminding him to bring his waders. He planned to drive Mike’s boat out to a deep area of Lake Seminole, push him in, allow the waders to quickly fill with water, pulling him under, causing him to drown.
After they drove separately to Lake Seminole, Brian told Mike to quickly put on his waders since they didn’t have much time. After they reached a deep area, Brian got Mike to stand up before he pushed him into the water. Rather than water filling his waders, pulling him under the surface, Mike was able to remove them as well as his jacket before swimming to a dead tree stump that stuck out of the water.
Brian said he loaded his gun, drove the boat over to Mike who was panicking. Panicking himself, he shot Mike in the head at close range before he was able to grab onto the boat.
Knowing he couldn’t leave Mike’s body there since he’d been shot, he dragged him to the shore, backed his Suburban down to the edge of the lake, put his body into the back & pushed Mike’s boat back into the water so it would look like he had drowned. Although he sped back to Tallahassee, he didn’t make it in time to meet his father-in-law at their planned time in order to establish an alibi.
With Mike’s body still in the back of his SUV, he went to Walmart to buy a shovel & a tarp before driving around for hours trying to figure out where he should bury him, settling on a remote area at the end of Gardner Road, miles from where Mike was raised.
He buried Mike’s body in a remote, marshy area along the shoreline of Carr Lake 61 miles from Lake Seminole & only 10 minutes from Brian’s house. He went on to say that he’s gone back to this spot nearly a dozen times over the years. Then he drove to a car wash to clean his car before driving up to Georgia for the family Christmas party.
Since Denise didn’t want to know the details of Mike’s death, she wasn’t aware that Brian shot Mike, but when his body wasn’t found in the lake, she could only assume that things hadn’t gone as planned.
After days of searching the Carr Lake area, on October 18, 2017, Mike’s body as well as his shirt, wedding band & gloves were found buried along the shoreline. He died from a 12-gauge shotgun blast to the face at point-blank range.

Eventually learning the full details from that morning, Mike’s family & friends were haunted by the idea that in his last seconds of life, he knew exactly what was happening & that his best friend was about to murder him.
They also believed that someone else had helped him that day, questioning Brian’s ability to carry out the crime by himself. He wasn’t a large, muscular man & everything had to happen so quickly so he wouldn’t be caught. They didn’t think he would have been able to pull Mike’s 5’10”, 170-180# soaking wet body from the water, load him into his Suburban, pull him back out & bury him all within a matter of hours.
When officers told Denise that her husband’s remains had finally been found after seventeen long years, she didn’t ask a single question; not where, not how, nothing.
After Brian entered a plea deal, pleading no contest to the armed kidnapping of Denise, he was sentenced to 20 years in prison on December 19, 2017. Denise had been in court that day, asking the judge to sentence him to life in prison since she feared that if he gets out, he’ll finish what he started.
Just one day after his sentencing, the FDLE held a news conference announcing that Mike Williams had been murdered. Because Brian had a deal with prosecutors, even though he admitted to killing his best friend, he wouldn’t be charged with his murder.
Mike’s family & friends were growing frustrated as months went by & still Denise hadn’t been arrested & charged with Mike’s murder.
Kathy contacted detectives about the damning message Denise had wanted her to pass to Brian via his dad, I’m not talking. They wanted Kathy to record Denise saying this, so she called her on February 13, 2018, lying that she had been subpoenaed to provide testimony about Mike’s murder. During their conversation, investigators were able to gather that Brian & Denise had a pact to stay silent about Mike’s murder.

Denise was arrested at work on FSU’s campus on May 8, 2018, her daughter’s 19th birthday. She was charged with first-degree murder, conspiracy to commit first-degree murder & accessory after the fact. After pleading not guilty to all charges, her trial began seven months later on December 11, 2018.

During his emotional, multi-day testimony, Brian Winchester confessed to shooting his best friend, Mike Williams, in the face with a shotgun as part of a murder plot that he & Denise had come up with. After they began their secret affair in October 1997, they wanted to be together permanently, but since Denise was against divorce, not wanting to share custody of their daughter or face the social stigma of divorce, murder became their agreed-upon solution.

Because Mike’s $500,000 life insurance policy was about to lapse, their window of opportunity was closing. They decided to go through with their plan on Lake Seminole during a duck hunting trip.
Although everyone in the courtroom cried during his testimony, Brian included, jurors couldn’t help but notice that Denise sat expressionless through it all.
After the trial ended on December 14, 2018, the jury deliberated for eight hours, finding Denise guilty on all three charges.
During her sentencing on February 6, 2019, Mike’s mom, Cheryl Williams made an emotional plea to the judge, asking that Denise spend the rest of her life behind bars. She went on to say that when she sleeps at night, she sees her son clinging to a tree stump in Lake Seminole in the dark, knowing that his best friend is trying to kill him. She hears his voice screaming for help, but she wasn’t there to help him, something that will haunt her forever.
Denise was sentenced to life in prison, something that didn’t come as a surprise since it’s mandatory for a first-degree murder conviction in Florida. For the conspiracy to commit first-degree murder, she was sentenced to 30 years with credit for time served. The accessory charge was dismissed since the law states that someone cannot simultaneously be an accessory in a murder they’ve been convicted of.
Denise had also been charged with three felony counts of insurance fraud since she fraudulently claimed Mike’s disappearance was an accidental drowning in order to collect $1.75 million in life insurance payouts. However, after she was convicted of first-degree murder & given a life sentence, these charges were formally dropped since pursuing the case was unnecessary.
Moving forward two years to November 2020, a Florida appeals court unanimously overturned her first-degree murder conviction, ruling that while she helped plan the crime, there was insufficient evidence to prove she physically participated in the actual murder or was there when it happened. Her conspiracy to commit first-degree murder conviction was upheld & she’s currently serving a 30-year prison sentence for that charge, meaning no one has been charged for Mike’s murder.
Her release date is scheduled for March 31, 2046 when she’ll be 76-years-old while Brian is serving his 20-year sentence for kidnapping & armed burglary & scheduled to be released in 2036 when he’s 66-years-old.

There are so many heartbreaking details in Mike Williams’ story, but the most haunting is what happened in his final moments. As he clung to the tree stump on that dark December morning, stunned after his best friend shoved him into the water, he was desperately trying to save himself. We can only imagine the fear, confusion & betrayal he must have felt in those last seconds of his life.

For 17 years, many people simply believed that Mike died in a tragic hunting accident. But his mom knew otherwise & never stopped fighting for the truth. In the end, the most heartbreaking part of this story isn’t just how Mike died, it’s that the people who were supposed to love & protect him were the very people who betrayed him.
References:
- Denise Williams v. State of Florida
- Hulu: Mr. & Mrs. Murder, S1, E1-4
- CBS News: Mother a driving force as jury finds answers to Florida man’s 2000 disappearance
- ABC News: ‘Partners in crime’: Florida couple’s affair leads to husband’s murder
- A-Z Animals: Alligator attacks: Do alligators eat people?
- Ati: Inside the chilling murder of Mike Williams at the hands of his best friend & his wife
- Yahoo news: Florida man’s disappearance reveals deadly plot between wife & best friend
- Tallahassee Democrat: Court records: Fears over Mike Williams case drove 2016 kidnapping by Brian Winchester
- WFSU: Williams trial day 2: Confessed shooter Winchester outlines motive, affairs
- WTXL: Insurance fraud charges dropped against Denise Williams
- WCTV: Denise Williams sentenced to life for husband’s murder
- Law & Crime: Denise Williams allegedly issued harsh ultimatum to murder victim’s family when they pushed for investigation
- A&E: Mike Williams’ wife & best friend killed him to be together
- New York Post: The mom at the center of a deadly love triangle with her high school sweetheart






