Watch on YouTube. Listen on Apple or Spotify.
No matter what we do in life or how hard we work, we all have the same amount of hours in a day & days in a year. None of us knows how much time we have in this world & oftentimes, we take it for granted, assuming there will always be more. Life doesn’t send warnings, there isn’t a countdown clock or an alert that tells us that this will be our last ordinary day. When we truly accept that time is limited & not ever guaranteed, we get that push to take that long-awaited trip, share our love more freely with those we care for, to hug a little longer & forgive a little faster.
This case reminds us that normal can disappear in an instant, even on a weekday morning that started as a completely ordinary day.
On Friday, March 16, 2012, 15-year-old Sierra LaMar got up & ready for school & headed out the door of her home in California toward her bus stop. But somewhere between her house & her bus stop, something happened to Sierra & her family has been searching for her as well as answers ever since.
Every year in the United States, there are more than 350,000 missing children reports made to law enforcement. Children can go missing for various reasons; some have run away, some are lost or injured while others are related to abductions, most of which are family-related as stranger abductions only account for 1% of missing children.
15-year-old Sierra LaMar sadly became a missing child statistic in 2012 when she left her Morgan HIll, California home that Friday morning for school. Despite the passage of 14 years, she has never been found, her family has been unable to lay her rest & they’re only left to imagine what could have happened to her as she left the safety of her home that day.
Sierra Mae LaMar was born on October 19, 1996 in Freemont, California to parents Steve & Marlene LaMar. She had a sister, Danielle, who was four years older. In October 2011, after her parents split up, a judge ruled that Sierra would live with her mom full-time. This decision, as well as the divorce itself, came after her dad Steve was convicted in 2007 after he was caught acting inappropriately toward one of Sierra’s friends during a sleepover.
After their split, Steve stayed in Fremont while Marlene & Sierra relocated 38 miles southeast to Morgan Hill to live with Marlene’s boyfriend, Rick Gardiner.
Being a very social teenager, Sierra was devastated to leave Fremont, the place she’d called home her entire life as well as all of her friends from Washington High School where she was a cheerleader. Five months before she vanished, Sierra was enrolled at Sobrato High School as a sophomore. Being a very likable, popular girl who easily made people laugh, she very quickly began making new friends.
Sierra made the 42 minute trip back to Fremont to catch up with her friends nearly every other weekend & it seemed that she was settling into a new normal. Marlene knew that her daughter wasn’t initially happy with the move, but since joining the cheerleading squad & growing her new friendships, she noticed that in the weeks before she vanished, Sierra seemed to be coming around.
Marlene had always viewed Sierra as her miracle baby since she was told that her likelihood of getting pregnant again was very slim due to her age. During an ultrasound, when she watched her baby doing somersaults in utero, she knew in her heart that her girl was going to be very strong-willed & she was right.
On Friday morning, March 16, 2012, Sierra got up for school at her usual time of 6 am to get ready for the day. Her mom popped into her bedroom to be sure she was up, she gave her a hug, told her she loved her & headed out the door for work a little after 6 am. Sierra was home alone at this point since Rick had left for work before she’d gotten up.
She posted a quick selfie to social media at 7 am & eleven minutes later at 7:11 am, she exchanged a text message with a classmate.
When Sierra left her house at about 7:15 am, she would have walked the few blocks to her unmarked bus stop at the intersection of Palm & Dougherty where the bus was scheduled to pick her up by 7:24 am. The land around her house was rural & unpopulated, so she was the only student at her stop.
Marlene sent her daughter a text message first at 6:57 am, asking her to remember to wipe down the tub & then at 9:45 am, asking if she was planning on getting together with a friend after school. Although Sierra hadn’t responded to either message, Marlene thought nothing of it, assuming her daughter was just preoccupied with her classes.
When Marlene left work at 3:45 pm, she called Sierra several times to check in, but she didn’t answer. Since she also hadn’t responded to her texts from that morning, worry began to set in. When she got home & realized that Sierra wasn’t there, her worry only grew because she was routinely home before her mom.
She drove over to the high school, but her daughter wasn’t there either so she called Steve as well as Rick’s daughter, who stayed with them every other weekend, but neither one had heard from her.
It wasn’t until 6 pm when Marlene received an automated e-mail from the school, informing her that Sierra had been absent from school that day. Now panicking, she called 911 at 6:27 pm to report her daughter missing. Nearly twelve hours had gone by since she left the house that morning, so crucial time had been lost.
Deputy Fabian DeSantiago responded to the call & met Marlene, Steve & Rick at the house. He contacted anyone associated with Sierra, but no one had heard from her or knew where she was. Each phone call made to Sierra’s cell phone that day had gone straight to voicemail, but on the final call that DeSantiago made at 3:48 am, now on Saturday morning, March 17, the line rang numerous times suggesting that the phone was turned on.
Since there was no evidence of foul play at this point in time, the Santa Clara County Sheriff’s Office considered Sierra a standard missing person. However, as time continued on & Sierra still didn’t come home, the investigation shifted to an involuntary missing person case under the umbrella of kidnapping & abduction.
Marlene told investigators that things had been very typical on the Thursday evening as well as Friday morning that Sierra vanished. She seemed completely herself & they hadn’t argued. On Thursday evening, they talked about a school project Sierra was working on related to teenage depression & suicide. She was trying to figure out what to write & since she liked writing, she seemed excited about the project. Marlene described her relationship with Sierra as very strong as her daughter would routinely confide in her about any issues she was dealing with.
When investigators spoke with Sierra’s bus driver, she indicated that she hadn’t gotten on the bus that morning. When she approached the stop Friday morning, she checked to see if Sierra was running late, but when she didn’t see her anywhere on the street, she continued on with her route.
That Saturday, an extensive ground & air search was conducted using Santa Clara County Search & Rescue workers as well as their equipment. A tracking dog was able to trace her scent to a point about halfway down her court which was not a through street, but then appeared to lose the scent.
According to Kurtis Stenderup, a Sheriff’s deputy who was trained in cell phone technology, Sierra’s phone was off the network from sometime after 7:11 am to 10:46 pm on Friday. It turned on & off several times, but each time it turned out, although it had only been for a moment, it was long enough to establish a location.
With this information, her black Samsung Galaxy cell phone was found later that day. It was lying intact in a field near the road along the intersection of Scheller & Santa Teresa in Morgan Hill, less than a mile from her house & not far from her bus stop.
The phone was screen-side up in the dirt with a small amount of water on the face as well as inside the battery compartment. It appeared to have been thrown out of a car, likely right after Sierra had been abducted. Since it had been exposed to water it caused the phone to turn on & off by itself, rather than a person doing so.
An analysis of the phone determined that she received a text from her friend Karissa at 7:05 am on Friday morning that read, Could you bring the stuff for me. She was referencing Sierra’s makeup, asking if she would bring it to school for her to use since her parents didn’t allow her to wear it. They also planned to compare their homework before class. At 7:11 am, Sierra responded, Y-E, meaning yeah. Although Karissa responded almost immediately, Sierra didn’t text back & then her phone was off the network from that point until 10:46 pm.
The next day, Sunday, March 18, her Juicy brand bag was located two intersections away from where her phone had been found at Laguna & Santa Teresa. It was lying between a barn & some cacti & held school papers, a black sweatshirt, jeans, a bra, a pair of grey shoes with a pair of underwear & a sock inside one of the shoes, all of which had been neatly folded. As was the case with her phone, it looked like the bag had been tossed from a car. According to Sgt. Randall, he thought the jeans smelled of human urine.
Because Sierra had taken a selfie that morning, investigators were able to see that the black San Jose Sharks sweatshirt in the bag matched what she was wearing in the photo. She’d borrowed the sweatshirt from her friend at school the day before & planned to wear it to school on Friday & then return it to her that same day. All of the clothing found in the bag had likely been what Sierra had been wearing when she left for the bus stop, meaning, she would have been stripped naked.
There were hundreds of microscopic glass beads found in her clothing that are often found in roadway paint to make the surface more reflective. This evidence gave investigators the impression that she had been lying on her back while someone dragged her by her feet.
After locating the bag, Santa Clara investigators began performing new, more extensive searches of the area which spanned a radius of three miles, involving fifty searchers plus dogs as well as divers who searched the nearby reservoirs. Parts of nearby Henry W. Coe State Park were also searched, an area with over 87,000 acres of expansive, rugged land 35 minutes from Sierra’s home.
They also looked into the extensive list of area sex offenders, however, each had a solid alibi. Sierra’s father, Steve, was very transparent about the fact that he was also a registered sex offender & like the others they looked into, he was ruled out as a person of interest by this stage.
Meanwhile, students & teachers from both her current school as well as Washington High School, posted hundreds of missing person signs around the Bay Area.
Not only had all of her social media activity ceased after the morning she left for school, but no one had seen or spoken with Sierra since that time in any way since 7:11 am. Prior to this point, Sierra was a typical teen who was extremely active on social media, communicating extensively with her friends.
Since she had no car, no driver’s license, no cell phone, no bank account or any source of money beyond what her parents provided her with, investigators were aware that she had no way of supporting herself. This made the idea that Sierra had voluntarily run away highly unlikely.
All of her belongings, including her money, house keys & the clothing she was wearing when she left the house that Friday morning, have all been found. Her asthma inhaler was also there, something she always carried with her, mostly using it during cheer competitions when she exerted herself.
After Sierra’s clothing was sent to the crime lab for analysis, forensic examination revealed the presence of DNA that was foreign to her, specifically on her jeans that was determined to be from semen. When the profile was entered into the Combined DNA Index System (CODIS), a search of the database identified a strong association to the DNA profile of 21-year-old Antolin Garcia-Torres, a father of a toddler who was expecting another baby in about six months.
The man’s DNA had been collected & submitted into the database two years earlier in 2010 when he was arrested for a felony crime. This ended up being dismissed while he was on probation following a misdemeanor conviction. Although the felony was dismissed that same year, his misdemeanor probation was extended.
When his DNA came up as a match in Sierra’s case, he had no record of a felony conviction in California or any other state.
Investigators were notified of the match & Antolin Garcia-Torres became a suspect on March 28, 2012, twelve days after Sierra went missing. They came to learn that Garcia-Torres lived about seven miles from Sierra’s home & drove a 1998 red Volkswagen Jetta with a black hood.
Authorities began monitoring Garcia-Torres 24/7 in hopes he would lead them to her, potentially finding her alive. Detectives tracked his movements with a GPS placed on his Jetta. They also scoured the Morgan Hill trailer he shared with his mom, his toddler daughter & his pregnant fiance, Francine Sarmiento. He was questioned multiple times beginning on April 4 & monitored around the clock for about two months.
He claimed that he never had any interaction with Sierra & she had nothing to do with his car. He worked in San Jose as an arborist, normally Monday-Thursday, starting his shift at 8 am. He was familiar with the area where Sierra lived & walked to the bus stop since he stopped at a bait & tackle store nearby.
Since he worked Monday-Thursday & Sierra went missing on a Friday, he had been off day. The Maple Leaf RV Park where he lived monitored the single entrace/exit with a security camera that proved he’d left that morning at 7 am. Initially the video made it appear that he hadn’t left until 8 am, which would have ruled him out as a suspect, but investigators realized that the camera hadn’t been adjusted for daylight savings time, meaning he left at 7 am. Since the RV park was a 10 minute drive to Sierra’s bus stop, this would have placed him there right within the window of when she was presumed to have been abducted between 7:11-7:25 am.
He claimed to have gone out fishing alone at Chesbro Reservoir where he worked his way around to Uvas Reservoir. However, he indicated that when he headed out that morning, he mistakenly drove past his normal turn & took a different route, placing him on Palm, the road that Sierra’s bus stop was on.
Multiple surveillance videos captured images of Garcia-Torres’ car in the area of Sierra’s house & where her belongings were recovered. After he went fishing, he said he stopped off at Bank of America, something that was proven by surveillance video at 12:50 pm.
Video evidence depicted him coming back home at 1 pm which would have given him about six hours to kidnap Sierra & then cover his tracks, including hiding her body.
On April 7, his car was seized by investigators & submitted to the crime lab for processing & analysis.
Criminalists found DNA that was foreign to Garcia-Torres in the car that when tested, had a strong association to Sierra’s DNA profile, suggesting that she had been inside his car. The evidence came from hair found on a rope as well as on the outside of a glove, each of which were found in his trunk. A match for her DNA was also found on one of the car’s armrests as well as on an interior rear door handle. Three polyester floormat fibers & two carpet fibers from Garcia-Torres’ car were similar to those found on Sierra’s sweatshirt & pants.
Investigators also discovered that he had purchased potential clean-up tools three days before she disappeared, including bleach & a turkey baster, one item that could destroy DNA while the other could be used as an applicator. Although he purchased the items, they were never found in his house when it was searched.
There was no evidence whatsoever to suggest that Sierra had previously known Antolin Garcia-Torres nor did they have any friends in common. Her family & friends had never seen nor heard of him prior to his arrest which would suggest that this had been an entirely random attack.
Evidence painted the picture that he forcibly kidnapped Sierra on her way to the bus stop. Although her body had not been found, investigators were certain that he murdered her. He had been driving near her bus stop in the timeframe she vanished, his DNA was found on her clothing, her DNA was found in his car & there was no evidence to support that she was still alive.
When his cell phone was analyzed to determine if there had been what is known as a digital intersection between his phone & Sierra’s, no connection was found.
Garcia-Torres was arrested in front of a Morgan Hill Safeway grocery store & charged with Sierra’s abduction & murder on May 21, 2012, a little over two months after Sierra disappeared.
On November 13, 2012, about six months after his arrest in relation to Sierra’s case, he was also charged with three counts of attempted kidnapping & carjacking, incidents that happened three years earlier in March 2009, to three women in two different Morgan Hill Safeway parking lots.
In one of the cases, the attacker tased a woman in the neck as she sat in her car in the grocery store parking lot, preparing to leave. He began punching her in the face until another customer came around & the man ran away. However, he dropped his taser in her car & Garcia-Torres’ fingerprint was found on a 9-volt battery inside the taser.
In each of these cases, the suspect was frightened away by the women’s screams or from a passerby. However, not one of the three women had been able to pick Garcia-Torres out of a photo lineup.
On February 11, 2014, the Santa Clara grand jury indicted Garcia-Torres, charging him with Sierra’s kidnapping & murder as well as the attacks on the three women in 2009. Two days later, he entered a not guilty plea.
Although Sierra’s body had not been found despite continued extensive searches for more than two years, nor had a crime scene or murder weapon been located, Santa Clara prosecutors indicated that they intended to ask for the death penalty against him.
On July 11, 2014, the court in Santa Clara County released the over 1,900 page grand jury transcript to the San Jose Mercury News. This was something Garcia-Torres’ defense attorney fought against, arguing that it would prevent him from having a fair trial due to the media attention. Some of the graphic details it contained had even been news to Sierra’s family.
According to the grand jury testimony, even before investigators brought up the physical evidence they had against him, Garcia-Torres tried to explain it away, making the assumption they had found his semen. He went on to say that he was embarrassed to admit that he liked to pleasure himself, something he did multiple times a day, oftentimes in his car. He would either throw the tissue he used to clean himself up in the garbage can or out the window of his car.
When he threw the saturated tissue out of the window of his car after Sierra disappeared, the material may have somehow gotten onto Sierra’s clothing, which had also been lying on the side of the road. However, the DNA evidence was found on Sierra’s jeans which had been folded inside her bag along the roadside.
Garcia-Torres’ defense team argued that the indictment should be dismissed, accusing prosecutors of omitting evidence indicating that Sierra had planned to run away on the day she went missing. They also argued that the physical evidence linking them together was weaker than portrayed, claiming that misleading statistics were presented in regards to his DNA being found on Sierra’s jeans.
When referencing evidence that Sierra planned to run away, they pointed out that after police searched Sierra’s locker, two notebooks were found with her writings. In her Spanish class notebook, she wrote, I hate my life.. No one ever sees this. I will be in San Francisco by 3/16/12 (the day she disappeared). In another she wrote, I really just wanna run away. She went on to write that she wanted to take a road trip to Las Vegas or Hollywood to get away from her problems.
However, a handwriting analyst from the Santa Clara crime lab testified that Sierra had probably not written the note. The high school’s assistant principal testified that he couldn’t remember which student turned the notebook in to the school administrators before he handed it to investigators. This was something prosecutor David Boyd dismissed as a cruel prank.
The defense also argued that tips had come through from people who believed they had seen Sierra after she vanished, one in Meyer Park in Fremont, the other at Conners State College in Oklahoma.
Dog scent evidence was also brought up as they tracked Sierra’s scent halfway down her court which was not in line with Garcia-Torres’path that morning. Since it was not a through street, they argued that he had no reason to drive that way & there was no evidence that he knew where Sierra lived or was where she was when she disappeared.
They also accused investigators of depositing Sierra’s hair on the rope found in Garcia-Torres’ trunk as initial images of the rope depicted no hair. In regards to the bleach & turkey baster he purchased three days before she vanished, they argued that the grand jury was never told that Sierra’s clothing showed no signs of damage from bleach.
In the meantime, after conducting 1,130 searches over the course of three years, on expert advice, Sierra’s family made the tough decision to stop searching for her on a weekly basis as they had been. In that time, more than 54,000 volunteer hours were spent making it the longest search center open in the U.S.
Garcia-Torres’ trial began on January 30, 2017. Since the trial covered not only Sierra’s abduction & presumed murder, but also the three attempted kidnappings from 2009.
His defense attorney, Alfonso Lopez, argued that there was an innocent reason as to why Garcia-Torres’ thumbprint had been found on the battery of the stun gun involved in one of the three attempted kidnapping cases. During that period of time, he had been working at Safeway, restocking items that shoppers ended up not purchasing. It was common for the package of batteries to break open which required Garcia-Torres to tape them closed before restocking. When he did so, he inadvertently transferred his thumbprint to one.
Since neither Sierra’s body, a crime scene nor a murder weapon had been found, prosecutors relied heavily on trace DNA during the trial.
When referencing the DNA involved in Sierra’s case, Lopez argued that it was found in such small amounts that it could have been transferred to these items by a third or fourth party from transfer contamination. When specifically mentioning the rope found in Garcia-Torres’ trunk, he argued that photos had not shown hair on the rope & the rope had been in evidence for four months before they found the hair.
Lopez argued that although microscopic glass beads had been found on Sierra’s clothing, none were found in Garcia-Torres’ car or on his belongings. Although prosecutors suggested that the beads had gotten there when Sierra was dragged across the pavement, no drag marks were found on the clothing that contained these beads.
Lopez dismissed the prosecution’s theory that Garcia-Torres purchased bleach & a turkey baster to destroy evidence, saying that he used bleach for typical household chores while the turkey baster was used for the illegal manufacturing of cannabis oil.
Over three months after the trial began, the jury began their deliberations on May 4, 2017 & five days later they came back with a verdict on May 9, 2017, finding Garcia-Torres guilty on all four counts, including first-degree murder. One month later, on June 5, 2017, he was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole.
Fast forward to nearly nine years after his sentencing, on Friday, February 27, 2026, the California Sixth District Court of Appeal overturned Garcia-Torres’ murder conviction. He may be entitled to a new trial because prosecutors improperly combined the unrelated 2009 kidnapping charges with the murder case, something that could have caused prejudice within the jury. According to legal analyst Steve Clark, the additional charges spilled over to him getting convicted of first-degree murder.
Garcia-Torres remains in prison while prosecutors decide if the case will return to Santa Clara County Superior Court or if they will appeal the decision to overturn the conviction & take it to the California Supreme Court.
What started as a normal school day for Sierra & a normal workday for Marlene, morphed into the worst day in their lives. Nothing about that morning suggested that it would be the last time they would ever see her. She snapped a selfie, texted a friend, grabbed her things & headed out the door like she always did.
Within seconds, this ordinary morning became a mystery that gripped a community & launched one of the largest search efforts in California history, leaving a family devastated & living each day with unanswered questions.
Although more than fourteen years have gone by since Sierra walked out of her house that Friday morning & never came home, her family still have no idea where she is. They are left to wonder what happened to her & they haven’t been able to bring her home to lay her to rest.
15-year-old Sierra LaMar would be celebrating her 30th birthday this October. She had been an outgoing, funny, engaging girl who countless people loved. Cases like hers remind us that when we wake up each morning, we believe that life will carry on as it always does. We never realize that as we say a goodbye & give a kiss to a loved one as we walk out the door, it can be for the final time. It’s a reminder to take an extra moment to make that phone call, send that text & do the small things we sometimes rush past. Life is precious & sometimes, it can be heartbreakingly short.
References:
- National Child Protection Task Force: Every missing child has a story
- Child Find of America: Facts & stats on missing children
- Santa Clara Courts: Statement of Facts
- ABC News: Missing CA girl Sierra LaMar’s mom sends her a mother’s day message
- ABC 7: 3 year search for Sierra LaMar comes to end
- ABC 7: Analyst: Seeking death penalty for Sierra LaMar suspect carries risk
- ABC 7: Timeline: Sierra LaMar kidnapping, murder case
- ABC 6: Search continues for missing teen from Morgan Hill
- NBC Bay Area: Sierra LaMar’s purse, clothing found
- NBC Bay Area: Details revealed in arrest of Antolin Garcia-Torres for murder/kidnap of Sierra LaMar
- NBC Bay Area: Conviction overturned for man found guilty in Sierra LaMar’s murder
- NBC Bay Area: ‘Sierra didn’t get a second chance’: LaMar’s dad talks about overturned conviction
- Office of the Attorney General: Arrestee DNA leads to arrest in suspects of Sierra LaMar abduction
- The Mercury News: Grand jury transcripts: Prosecutors say Sierra LaMar’s hair on rope in suspect’s car
- People of the State of California vs. Antolin Garcia Torres
- Ati: The chilling disappearance & murder of Sierra LaMar
- The Crime Talk: Sierra LaMar
- Medium: The disappearance & murder of Sierra LaMar
- Morgan Hill Times: Attorney: No evidence that Sierra LaMar is dead
- SF Gate: DNA evidence comes under attack in murder trial of South Bay teen
- YouTube: Kendall Rae: High school girl kidnapped on her way to the bus: The case of Sierra LaMar
- Fox KTVU: Witnesses testify about ‘runaway note’ found in Sierra LaMar’s notebook
- Fox 2: Sierra LaMar case: Convicted killer may get new trial
